Post Info TOPIC: Devaraja Market: mayor has spoken
GVK

Date:
Devaraja Market: mayor has spoken
Permalink   


The city mayor, Ms bharathi, has spoken. The heritage structure has to go. She tells ‘The Hindu’ (Dec.8, 2005), “even if the market is restored under the guidance of architects, it will not last more than 20 years”.


Ms.Bharathi’s prescription: bring down the old, build a new structure. The mayor has in mind a two-storey shopping complex, with parking space in the basement.


If we go by her word, the plan for Devaraja market may well be finalised by Dec.-end, when the raze-and-rebuild proposal would be placed before the city municipal council.  


 



__________________
Bhamy Shenoy

Date:
Permalink   


I am inclined towards demotion, and building Deveraj Market anew, to meet the citizens needs, but keeping the same façade of the heritage building. However before doing that one would like to see an integrated plan developed, incorporating a new  Makkaji chowk, new Deveraja Market and any other corporation and private buildings that may be demolished/restored. Such a plan should show what would be the traffic flow, how parking needs will be taken care of; how will cleanliness be maintained, how will water needs will be met, how will sewage be handled etc.  We need to learn from our bad experience of ad-hoc planning. Bhamy Shenoy


 


 

 


__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

Demolishing the existing Devaraja Market seems to be the only solution for every growing population and also the authorities can control on who can set up shops within the new premises. This will surely provide better avenues to the authorities by means of better rentals and better maintainance.


By having a new structure, we can accommodate proper drainage system, proper garbage disposal, proper exit and entry points, facilitate proper parking, can curb vendors on the footpaths inside and outside the market and finally provide better selling and buying environment to both.


The Devaraja Market building can be re-built as per the present exterior design or probably with addition of two floors with a basement for exclusively for parking and sanitation facilities.


One common problem every commercial complex and commercial streets face is the parking of vehicles. The shop owners usually occupy the parking space well provided for the public parking. This has to be avoided, the authorities need to allot parking space for individual shop owners separately and also for the general public visiting the Market.


If we restore the present Market, by plastering a few walls, water proofing the roof, re-pianting the walls and similar such works, we can never regulate the vendors selling their wares inside the market.. We can never have a clean market, free from garbage or vegetable waste...


We need to provide a crash training session educating the shop owners about ways to dispose the waste. Generally we have seen flowerists dumping the lose flowers in the pathway, we have seen the banana plantain and plantian leaves dealers dump the waste in the pathway, we have seen the fruit shop owners dump the packing materials like boxes, baskets in the pathway.. so on and so forth.. we surely need to get them to dispose off their waste in a very tidy and proper manner to maintain the cleanliness of the Market. Not to forget the vegetable dealers washing and sprinkling water on the vegetables to keep them fresh, but they fail to understand that by doing so.. they are creating problems in the pathway..


Whatever might the result be .. new building or restoring the old building we need to educate one and all about using the facility.



__________________
Ramaprasad

Date:
Permalink   

!n early 1950 's there was this Kannada evening news paper Sadvi 3ps per copy. It carried a note that a boy sliped on a banana skin and broke his leg in Devaraja market ( Which was always kept meticulosly clean.) The boys father filed a police complaint and the local Magistrate Sri. Sankar iyer awarded damages to the boy. The amount was Rs20.The municipality had to pay this for not having kept the market clean. Can this happen to day- the municipality will go bankrupt!

__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

Dear Ramaprasad,


You have the question and the answer too.. :)


 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

There must be a better solution to the Devaraja Market problem than mere demolition of a heritage, 110 year old structure. The honorable mayor says that the old structure, even if renovated, will not last for more than 20 years. Well, looking at the quality of construction these days, especially government funded projects that invite the lowest bids by tender, can the mayor guarantee that a new structure built will last more than 20 years? I doubt that. When you look at new structures built by the corporation for markets and see how ugly, badly planned and dank they are, one may expect more of the same at the Devaraja Market if a so called “modern” structure is built. There are many heritage structures around the World and a lot of them in India that have survived well when maintained properly, for hundreds of years. Let’s face it, what is the number one attraction about Mysore? Is it Industry and Trade or is it tourism? Tourism is the back bone of the local economy. Preserving and conserving heritage structures, therefore, is vital to developing tourism. The Devaraja market is listed on many travel books such as on “Lonely Planet”. I know lots of overseas visitors that use such books to plan their holidays. Yours truly has also used such books when visiting countries in South East Asia on holiday and countries of Guatemala and Honduras on business and holiday. Heritage building and structures reflect the culture of the people of the city/area/region and that’s why they are listed in guide books and provide an attraction for visitors to travel to such places. I am sure that there are architects in Mysore that are good enough to give advice on renovation and conservation methods and save the structure from crumbling. Maybe the answer lies in keeping the façade as it exists (but restored) and strengthening or renovating the support structures so that the important architectural parts of the building are still the original 110 years old.

__________________
Srinivas Rao

Date:
Permalink   

Honorable Mayor, and distinguished audience:


Culture, language, traditions, architecture are really what makes a place more welcome.


Culture, which may (? I am unsure) be linked with Kala (art, and said another way time) and (Aachar which is 'reethi' or practice) does change but is raely sudden. As a matter of fact none of the 4 listed above ever change suddenly. Unless of-course when one is driven out.


Preserve the facade and change the interior that is a much more pleasant solution.


If expansion is a must one ought to look at alternative locations with ample parking. What is a killer today in most parts of all cities is the lack of parking. Mass transit may be effective, however the younger generation is welcoming the freedom of driving. For once we are seeing the youth positioned well, earning well and spending well and thus creating a successful economy. It is this that is driving change. Change is necessary. But know where and how to work or effect change.


Hence altering the Devaraja Market is affecting the landscape of Mysore and that means a lot to a large bunch of us; and importantly offers very little. The area is quite crowded with pedestrian traffic. Any addition will make it impossible to shop. Could we target an alternative location for a jumbo sized super structure to house the conveniences of a 'mall' and ensure there is adequate parking facilities as well?


Srinivas



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

The mayor has spoken again. She now "seeks public opinion" about Devaraja Market and mentions in the newspapers that she invites suggestions, to be sent to Mysore Corporation, within a week (today is Saturday 17th december 2005).


The Indian Express has also given a fax number of the Mysore City Corporation for sending letters connected with this. The number is 252 9033. For those Mysoreans residing out of State and want to send their suggestions, I would like to remind them to dial as 0821-252 9033 and those Mysorens residing aborad, +91 821 252 9033.


I personally feel that the current facade must be retained and perhaps structures within may be renovated and strengthened. The mayor, in the Indian Express, says that the market was designed for a Mysore population of 90,000 in the 1880's and cannot handle the 1 million plus polpulation that exists today.


The answer may be to construct markets and malls in areas outside the city centre to discourage 1 million residents from coming to the city centre to the Market (like thats whats been happening so far!).



__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

The Mayor has done the right thing of asking the public opinion and arriving at a solution to solve the situation.


We all know that something or the other needs to be done to the Devaraja Market, but what is that we need to do.. we all can come out with a possible economic and socio feasibility solution. We need to come out with a proper solution and see to it that it will be the best suited to everybody concern.


Thanks Capt. Anup for providing the numbers to voice our suggestions.


Having malls around in the extentions areas might not work out.. the one built at Vijayanagar Kalidasa Road seems to unoccupied and there a few markets which are not occupied fully. General mind set is anything purchased at Devaraja market will be cheaper as compared to extention areas malls.. so what is the use in setting up malls or markets around the town.


How can we prevent people coming over the City Centre to purchase? How can we avoid habits that have been inculcated over years.. People have been shopping at Devaraja Market for nearly 100 years.. Old habits die hard!!


Thinking one step ahead, whatever might be the outcome of Devaraja Market whether restoration or new building.. We need see to it that we have another alternative arrangement till the time the works are completed. It should become another place like the Vegetable open market on MG Road.


The administration before banning selling vegetable at the Gunhouse area, they should have made sure that the place earmarked and alloted has to have all the facilities of parking, toilets, refreshments etc., and not entertain unorganized & unauthorised development..


My suggestion is rebuild the Devaraja Market and till the new market is built temporarily shift the Vendors to JK grounds with temporary structures not affecting the ground.. I would have suggested the place near Hardinge cirlce and Doddakere Maidan (Exhibition Ground Parking area) But no not that place as my observation, I have seen people playing football, cricket matches very often. But JK Grounds, I haven't seen much activity happening Or Makkaji Chowk Area but it is not pratical!!


Lot depends on how much funds can the authorities generate and how they can generate? Looking at the present situation, no one knows how they are going to generate such huge funds whether it is for restoration or for the new structure.


This Devaraja Market issue is just at the beginning, we have lot more issues arising out of this, we need to tackle them at the beginning and then get on with a plan.


For everything that is been implemented in our city, we have witnessed opposition and confrontations and by just opposing the implementation, the project suffers with time schedules not being kept and thus the project costs hikes up and then all the problems strike back like a boomarang!!


Any solutions? not suggestions please!! 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

I agree with Mr. Yerapathi's observation about people's mindset. There's one thing that bothers me and I'm sure it bothers a lot of people, thats the money required for the project. Does the corporation have the money? Are they relying on the State Government (God forbid!) for funds? The project must have funding and planning in place before they start knocking things down. The plan must have time-bound completion. Otherwise we'll end up with an eyesore in the middle of Mysore!


There are various Government/corporation funded projects that have taken forever and some that have been left incomplete in between for a variety of reasons as Mr. Yerapathi has articulated. See the roads in Mysore and the promises that they made to Mysoreans before Dasara. I wonder if the Heritage Commission has funds ready for restoration at least.


It is difficult to trust the corporation on any of these accounts. How can a body that has no money for road repairs, no means of providing adequate water supply to the city, no drive of any kind be trusted to undertake a project of this size. Their lack of planning ahead resulted in some roofs of some of the shops in the market to fall. Luckily there were no customers inside at that time. Our "leaders" will only wake up when there are people hurt or worse. Untill the sky falls on our heads, they will have no contingency measures.


How do we ensure that all our suggestions are taken, understood and implemented? The current organizations that frequently protests to the Corporation on various issues are at loggerheads with each other. I don't suppose they can be effective.


Lets start with writing to the Mayor with our suggestions (and hope it does not end up in the "circular file").


Solutions: Get consensus from all traders at the market about rehabilitation and temporary relocation (any of the venues suggested by Mr. Yerapathi sounds feasible). Get the planning done. Get the funding in advance. Keep the heritage facade as is. Build the interior capable of expanded facilities. Importantly, award the tender to a company/group that has good experience in this field, not someone who quotes the lowest and we end up with a sand castle thats not going to last a few years.


I guess, easier said than done.


 


 



__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

I am half tempted to write my suggestions to the Mayor, I am also wondering like Capt. Anup, that it might turn out be just another circular.


Infact, given an opportunity, I would like take part in collating & analysing the information/suggestions received by the Mayor.


I did try speaking to one trader at the Market, a banana trader, according to him, they are paying 200/- per month as rent.. I was really surprised at that figure and he said that the corporation in its proposal is asking for Rs. 5000/- pm with a 11 month agreement!! (which i consider is very fair). Going by my interaction with him, the vendors want to have the cake and as well eat the cake too.. (this was a casual talk with him while I was buying bananas from him)


I think we need to take out a survey among all the traders, hawkers & users to ascertain as to what  needs to be done, what is their requirement and then ask them a few open ended questions like how they want to improve the situation etc.,


This would be more like a Consumer Satisfaction Survey, which would help us in carrying out the feasibility study at a later date. On completion of the feasibility study, we would know as to how much fund would be required and how long it would take to establish a new or renovated market.


While we are at that.. we also should imbibe this rule of "Pay by Use" system, for eg., if the vendors are using the parking system they pay an upfront charge, if they use the water, power resources they pay a upfront fee!! every month the authorities can charge a Maintenance fee to the vendors for upkeep of the facilities like drinking water and sanitation.


For the public, the authorities make sure that we the public don't use plastics, if found with useage the fine them heftly.. the same goes to the vendors too.. make it a mandatory not to sell goods in plastic!!


While I am typing this, my mind is racing with the after effects that we the citizens of Mysore might face.. most important one is the prices of commodities hiked up.. we usually get to experience this effect when there is a petrol hike or a transport strike.. so we all know... if the corporation is going to ask big rentals.. then we the people need to pay a higher price.. then we are back to square one!


What do really need to do?


 I started to asking questions to myself and search for answers within me.. at very stage I happened to come back to same situation where I started from.. All said and done.. We need to conduct a research and get to know what is the feel. No point in cracking our brains, trying to muster all the data and providing suggestions and remedies!! coz no one is going to compromise!! Its only we the people who have to suffer.. oops.. compromise!!



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

Time to draw a line. This morning (22 Dec) the Indian Express says that talks between the Mayor and the Traders of Devaraja Market have broken down. Both sides stuck to their agenda, it seems. The Mayor and the MCC commissioner are hell bent on demolishing the structure and building something "on heritage Lines". This means something real ugly, I know that these people will not be able to replace the current building. The traders stuck to their position of renovating the existing market.


If the mayor and the MCC have all along made up their mind about demolishing the market, why then, did she ask the citizens to send in their suggestions and comments "within 7 days"? Why make citizens waste their time and energy if they had a pre-conceived plan of demolishing the structure?


Time to draw the line. My position is clear. No ad hoc demolition. As mentioned earlier, keep the facade, renovate the rest, strengthen the structure, have a proper plan for restoration that is time bound, SHOW PROOF OF FUNDS (MCC this means you) that shows the capability of the MCC to undertake this task.



__________________
GVK

Date:
Enter at your peril
Permalink   


Like they do on liquor ads. and cigarette packs (carrying statutory health warnings) the municipal corporation is reported to have fixed a notice at the Devaraja Market entrance, cautioning that those who enter the market premises would do so at their peril. The run-down and weather-ravaged roofs can collapse anytime, says the notice, adding that traders were not co-operating with the civic body in initiating restoration work.


(Source – The Hindu, Dec.22, 2005)


 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
RE: Devaraja Market: mayor has spoken
Permalink   


Interesting to read The Hindu news quote posted by GVK. Similar signs may need to be posted at half of Mysore's "heritage" buildings including Lansdowne Building, Jagan Mohan Palace (I last went there with a guest two months back and there were extensive dampness, seepage and cracks in the building) and other such buildings. The MCC demolition drive probably will next target Lansdowne Building for sure. It's a surprise that Lansdowne Building has not had its roof and walls collapse.


MCC knows nothing about restotation and maintenance, it seems. they only know one thing and that is "Demolition"!! 



__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

After reading GVK's post on Corporation sticking notices and the entrance.. I guess the corporation is being cautious & safeguarding their stand for any claim on damage that is foreseen!!


My assumption "I think the corporation thinks that Restoration is an expensive process.. so why not demolish the whole structure and rebuild where some of the materials can be recycled or reused.. and they think rebuilding cost would be cheaper.


Now the newspapers are screaming that the Mysore Dasara Exhibition Grounds to be made as a temporary market..


So what will happen to the Dasara Exhibition 2006? Would the market be completed by then?


To provide temporary arrangment to the vendors at Dasara Exhibition grounds would require regular power connection and water facilities.. But by providing such facilities the cost would be very high.. the corporation needs to take a feedback whether that place is acceptable by the vendors or not!!


The compromise we need to do is let the Authorities do what they intend to do with Devaraja Market and we should associate closely with the authorities in putting the plan across in a more feasible way!


the saying goes this way.. "if you can't change the system, try joining the system, if you can't join the system then quit the system"


 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   


With due respects, I think the chaps at MCC want demolition and building new structure. I don’t think they ever intend to re-use or re-cycle or repair. There’s no chance that the market can be demolished and completed again in one year. Again, where is the proof of funds? These people at MCC say no funds, so no road repair. No funds for improving water supply. Where will they get this money?


 


My take (apologies to GVK’s blog heading “My Take”!) on this matter is that if the MCC involves private citizens to work with them jointly, that will become a transparent project and they will avoid this at all costs. Transparent means no corruption! No "under the table moolah" for awarding contracts, purchase of materials, passing the bills for payment etc. Oh Boy!


 


The only way is to fight the system in a proper and legal manner, forcing the authorities to be transparent. Involving the public again is a contentious issue with so many organizations claiming to represent the citizens of Mysore. How many people can be let into a committee and what are their backgrounds and agenda’s? Are they thinking of Mysore and its betterment or just free publicity to be a “somebody” in Mysore society?


 


I’d wait to see what the MCC comes up with. If it is a unilateral MCC demolition decision without consulting all parties and making a mockery of the “invite for suggestions by the mayor from the citizenry”, without making provisions for a plan, money etc, then my mind is made up. I’m going to fight and there are lots of people who would, I’m sure.


 


In the US, important decisions are taken in a "town hall" meeting where the mayor and council members ask the public in a discussion and debate format. This is not the US but another great democracy. Let’s be aware of that. We have to remind these people that they are "elected" representatives and need to involve the people in important decisions.


 


 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

I stand vindicated. Today's Star of Mysore 17th Dec has two articles. Reading both, it is clear that MCC has decided on demolition and re-building. I have decided to write to SOM and copy of that letter is hereunder for any one to read. I hope SOM publishes it:


Sir,


In SOM dated 17th December 2005: “Devaraja Market: Mayor goes to public court”, the Hon. Mayor of Mysore gave a statement saying that she wants to seek the opinion of the public and that citizens must write within seven days etc. Today’s SOM dated 22nd December 2005 has two articles one about the mayor asking traders to decide within five days in which the demolition decision is mentioned by the commissioner as he mentions that “permission from heritage Task force is not necessary for demolition of the dilapidated structure” and another article “Corporation receives designs for Devaraja Market”. When reading both these articles, the impression is clearly that the MCC has decided to demolish the structure and build another one. Commissioner in this article mentions that suggestions from individuals and organizations will also be taken under consideration. Firstly, if the MCC had already decided that demolition is the name of the game, why did they ask the public opinion? What if the public don’t want demolition but restoration? In what way will the MCC take suggestions under “consideration” when something has been pre-decided? Secondly, for a corporation that cries about lack of funds every time someone mentions that roads that were promised to be repaired before Dasara haven’t been repaired or when water supply issues are raised. Now, where would the funds for demolition and re-construction come from? Thirdly, after Devaraja Market, the “demolition drive” is sure to hit Lansdowne Building and then Jagan Mohan Palace since there is a lot of seepage, cracks and the building looks dilapidated in several rooms etc. This Heritage City will loose its tag as soon as we start to loose all the heritage structures.  Where is the will to look at alternatives?


Capt. Anup Murthy


 



__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

I would say lets wait and watch.. assumptions is the mother of all problems.. so lets not assume.. lets give the authorities that yard stick..


 


We are not sure or don't know what the MCC has up their sleeves? they might have an ace for all you know.. For all you know.. or guess, they might come out with a BOT - Build, Operate Y Transfer option where their investments would be very low.. 


 


If a big company like L&T or Prestige Group or some other infrastructure companies come then it is possible for them to achieve that one year target..


 

Forcing the authorities to be transparent.. will never work or might not work.. because they are not liable to answer to anyone!!

 


With respect to consulting the citizenry and coming to an understanding.. we the citizen would know what is happening only if the publications carry investigative and a updated articles on this issue...


 


The newspaper houses in Mysore City are not helping the situation any better, they could have taken this opportunity to conduct an opinion poll and publish the same and do a comparision with the authorities and the research findings.


 


Every coin has two sides.. and i think we are seeing only one side and the other side is not known to us..


 


So lets wait and watch.. some time back.. every local newspaper screamed about Makkaji Chowk area.. but after three or four days we don't get to hear about it now.. thatz where we crux.. we the people are not well informed !!


 


 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

I don’t mean to hog all the space (and hope there are other who will express their opinions as well) I changed the last para of my letter to SOM, here it is:


“This Heritage City will loose its tag as soon as we start to loose all the heritage structures. Imagine tour guides explaining to tourists, pointing to Devaraja market and saying that this used to be a heritage building but now it only looks like one but actually isn't! Look at buildings built by the MCC and see their condition today. When the MCC goes for the least cost tender, the building contractor is sure to take short cuts and then what would be the condition of the re-built market? Where is the will to look at alternatives?”


 


I doubt BOT will be viable. If a big builder comes and does a JV, it has to be commercially highly profitable (not merely viable). No trader will agree to pay high rentals that a BOO or BOT venture with big name builders. I know some of these big name builders and big profits is the only name of the game. Nothing wrong with that, though. Unless big name builders know of additional source of revenue that they can make from this project and is willing to take a Rs.200 rent from fruit sellers, it aint gonna happen. This is not like Makkaji Chowk. This is an actual building in various stages of disrepair and falling roofs. The MCC needs to do something fast and I doubt this issue will go quiet after some time. I wrote a letter to SOM. That may be published and may evoke some response.



__________________
GVK

Date:
The heritage versus ecomoics option
Permalink   


Capt. Anup Murthy wrote:


   In the US, important decisions are taken in a "town hall" meeting where the mayor and council members ask the public in a discussion and debate format. This is not the US but another great democracy. Let’s be aware of that. We have to remind these people that they are "elected" representatives and need to involve the people in important decisions.    


I read a newpaper report quoting the commissioner (or is it the mayor?) that restoration would cost 50 percent or more of what it would cost to raze the place to ground and rebuild. I don't suppose you need to be a commissioner or an economist to see that heritage conservation may not be good economics. There is no such thing as cut-price heritage. At the risk of being dubbed a wet blanket I propose the heritage option (read painstaking restoration) wouldn't be worth the cost, if the structure is going to be used as a market place, housing the same lot of traders whose interest in the place is its prime location, not heritage. A redone Devaraja Market ought to be used as town museum, or venue for cultural events. To cite an analogy, not an appropriate one, perhaps, the Andamans cellular prison, preserved as a heritage place, is not being used as jail.


A town hall hearing might help generate some light/heat on the heritage versus ecoonomics option, and the proof-of-funding issue that needs clearing up before we proceed, considering our civic body's unenviable track record. 



__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
RE: Devaraja Market: mayor has spoken
Permalink   


GVK’s comment has some solutions contained within it. I agree that the new market must be built on another spot, perhaps Makkaji Chowk (!!). The existing Devaraja Market converted into a heritage museum, venue for classical music events etc. If such an activity is proposed at this location, funds may be forthcoming from State Government grants, Central Government grants, private grants, heritage Task Force funds (if they are empowered) and corporate grants. Infosys has in the recent past funded restoration work on a heritage building in Mysore. More corporate sponsors may be found.


 


The fruit, vegetable, meat, shops and whatever else exists at Devaraja Market may be shifted to the new venue. The new venue may have adequate parking, water and sanitation facilities. No need to demolish and rebuild the existing market edifice, adding to the cost.


 


Maybe this is what a few of us can suggest to the MCC in writing. A town hall meeting is also a good idea. Any suggestions how something like this can be organized? I invite comments and suggestions from many other browsers of mymysore.com



__________________
GVK

Date:
Permalink   

Heritage commissioner Mr Ramakrishna says, " I was not informed about the demolition plan at all". He is quoted, (page one bottom-spread), in Deccan Herald (Dec.23, 2005) as saying that demolition would spell doom to the heritage value of the century-old building. 

__________________
Suresh Yerapathi

Date:
Permalink   

The town hall meeting is a very good option, incidentally yesterday, two students from SDM institute came to me with a questionnaire asking about pre dasara, dasara and post dasara .. benefits to me and to the economy.... I have requested them to speak to the college management to conduct a similar kind of research for the Devaraja Market, as they have assured me that they will take up to the college management with this issue.. Lets see what they can do about it..


But again for whatever we do.. it will be a waste of time and energy and resources!! The final decision is due in another four or five days..


 



__________________
MajGen SG VOMBATKERE(Retd)

Date:
Permalink   

That something has to be done for Devaraja Market, there is no doubt. But to plump for the demolition-reconstruction (D-R) or for repair-rehabilitation (R-R) option has to be based on some logic and figures. This what is not happening. Irrational decisions are what we have to guard against. Being "inclined" towards an option is only "gut feeling" that has no place in city planning.
Citizens HAVE to be consulted - Officials who are tenure-based have no long-term stake in the City - even elected officials have no business to decide without consulting their constituencies .
There are four parties to this issue - MCC ()the custodian of the property), Traders (who are occupants-tenants), Civil Society (the owners of the property), and the Heritage Committee of Mysore (who have the expertise).
Let's see how the cookie crumbles this time around!!

__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

Star of Mysore this afternoon 24th Dec issue has a large write-up on the Devaraja Market issue. The author is none other than the editor Mr. K.B. Ganapathy. The article has less of Mr. Ganapathy's thoughts and more of MGP's view points. Its almost like an MGP newsletter.


I must commend the MGP for their viewpoints and observations mentioned in the article. The article also mentions that MGP is in favour of holding multilateral discussions with the various stake holders. Isn't that what we have been discussing in this forum, calling it a "Town Hall meeting"? It is good that there seems to be similar trains of thought here amongst the people.


I hope other citizens, not aligned to MGP or any other organization are also allowed to participate as they should be, each citizen being a stake holder, in my opinion.


The MGP also suggests just two options. One is Repair and Rehabilitation (RR) or demolition and reconstruction (DR). I beg to differ with the MGP on the aspect that there are only two options. There is a third option. That has been articulated by GVK in this forum. Move the whole market out. Build a new market elsewhere, maybe Makkaji Chowk! Existing structure to be repaired and rehabilitated (to use their own words) and converted into a Heritage Museum or art and music centre etc. 


MGP has also mentioned "some of the factors that need to be considered by the stake holders" comprising of 11 points. The most important point to me, is missing. What is the unseen monetary benefit of having this heritage building restored. 


Mysore attracts visitors because it is heritage city. What is the value of Mysore without its heritage buildings? Zero. I repeat, ZERO. Several costs have been mentioned in the article such as capital cost, maintenance cost etc. People are looking at cost only NOT at value. What is the Heritage value of the Building. Can that be replaced with the options mentioned by MGP? Absolutely not. As soon as DR happens, the heritage VALUE drops several levels. Its like saying that since there are cracks in the Qutb Minar, better to  demolish it and build a new one so that visitors are safe! I could use many other examples. Monuments are to be saved, regardless of how much it costs. Devaraja Market is a living monument.


As a true blue Mysorean whose family is living here since Krishna Raja Wadiyar III, perhaps our sentiments are not easily understood by recent Mysoreans when they talk of DR.



__________________
GVK

Date:
Permalink   

Capt. Anup Murthy wrote:


 MGP is in favour of holding multilateral discussions with the various stake holders. Isn't that what we have been discussing in this forum, calling it a "Town Hall meeting"?

The 'Town Hall meeting' Capt. Murthy refers to is not an option. It is, as I understand, mandatory.The local authorrities should be required to convene town hall hearings to elicit views of the people (which includes, NGOs, traders, heritage-minded folk, and all the rest of us un-labeled residents) and clarify their apprehensions and misgivings before any project of public interest is finalised. It is time we thought of institutionalisng this practice  in the interest of transperancy and public accountablity. When once a project gets okayed at a town hall hearing the authorities could have a free hand to go-ahead with the project without  further activist-driven hassles.

__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

I wrote a letter to star of mysore and posted it on this issues board as well. It has been published today, 25th december in Voice of the Reader. The letter has been edited, perhaps for space. No matter. For those who wish to read this in the paper but are not subscribers or live outside Mysore, the letter may be accessed on the net: http://starofmysore.com/main.asp?type=vor


In yesterday's Star of Mysore, there was a full page article written on behalf of MGP. I have written to SOM on this article as well and hope that gets published. There should be divergent points of view in any democratic society and I am glad that SOM does publish all points of view and is not biased. My endeavour is not to malign or sideline MGP or any other organization that is doing good work in Mysore, it is to merely put a different point of view. I have come to know that there are several persons of high esteem who are a part of such organizations and they are doing selfless work.


The end result of all this writing and blogging is to somehow in a small way contribute to bringing awareness of this issue in particular and I am hopeful that people will see this kind of activity, take part in the deliberations and force the authorities (read MCC elected reps and appointed officials) to include such different points of view. Of course I am glad that I am in a country where such divergent views can be so easily shared through any kind of media boldly. Thats the freedom that we should appreciate and use that freedom to ensure checks and balances are there in the system. I am sure MGP and others are also trying to, in their own way, ensure proper checks and balances with respect to Mysore issues.



__________________
H.R.Bapu Satyanarayana

Date:
Permalink   

    My perception is that we have to see opening of an opportunity in the collapse of two shops in Devaraja Market. This clearly impacts on future planning in the light of the explosive development taking palce in IT sector. From the media reports I find that by March 2006 employment opportunity for 20,000 is being created. I presume that it is only in IT sector since nearly 4000 is in Infosys. If so it will generate employment in other ancillary industries and in tertiary areas on domestic and office  front like maid servants, drivers, etc. Thus taking a holistic view the employment  would be anywhere about one lakh and above in the immediate future. By any standard this is an enormous addition to the present 10 lakh population. Since I am conversant with  traffic issue, the immediate impact would be the sudden addition of vehicle population and the parking problem which is posing a problem now. That is how this collpase has an immediate reference to what should be the type of development that should take place in Makkaji Chowk. My sincere opinion is that it should be reserved mainly for parking. Also as I have never been tired of suggesting that the Devaraja Market stretch shoudl be converted into  a pedestrian mall. Surveys indicate that in pedestrian areas  the trade florishes musch more. The new buildings may be constructed keeping the same heritage appearance but refurbished to serve as modern shopping and the whole stretch should be a covered one. this not only serves as a via media arrangement to satisfying the modern trend for new look shopping and at the same time get out of the 'Mall mindset'  which is creating a great social upheaval in making the  small shopowners/traders an extinct species. In fact in metros like Delhi, Bombay etc  a great debate is going  on this issue when the modest small residential traders are finding it difficult to exist since  the shopping in Malls has set a new trend. On no account Mysore should  fall into this trap. We must unclutter our thinking as nothing in life is unconnected and it sets a chain reaction aand wisdom lies in seeing the larger picture.

__________________
Capt. Anup Murthy

Date:
Permalink   

Todays Star of Mysore dated 27th dec has another letter of mine (Voice of the reader) published in the print edition on the front page. The ideas reflected in the letter are a combination of views presented in this forum. Mr. GVK has mentioned clearly about the third option. There are related articles in "arts for all" and "Art boulevard", perhaps a hint that this venue may be used for the exhibition of arts and culture.


That the MGP, ACICM, Mr. Ganapathy (ed SOM) and Mr, Ravi Gundu Rao has approached the DC to intervene and stop the MCC from taking a hasty decision is a welcome move. It is timed well and I support them in forcing the MCC to adopt a democratic process. the SOM editorial also mentions this needs to be supported.


Visitors to this board are encouraged to put in their views. I know there are plenty of opinions out there and some people have no other avenues to express their opinions. Please remember that fora like this is an essential means for spreading the word on the different opinions of Mysore citizens regarding various issues. Stand up and be counted. Thats how democracy works.



__________________
madhukar

Date:
Permalink   

Although I have recently joined the myMysore group, somehow the Devaraja Market has always been close to my heart.

I remember during the sixties when I was a small kid, whenever any one mentioned "Let's go the the Market" it always meant "Devaraja Market" - no other market would do - not even the "Chikka (Vanivilasa) Market" (near Siddappa Square) - which was closer to our home in Chamarajapuram. We always enjoyed the outing - the bargaining for vegetables, the shopping of provisions and puja articles at Shettara Angadi near the south entrance (He is still giving his customers kallusakkare or dry grapes at the time of settling the bill) or purchasing Nanajangudu rasabale in the shop opposite (now it has converted to a bangle shop) all the while tagging along behind my grandfather and grandmother.

We never were happy buying footwear any where other than "Big BATA showroom" - still going great at the north east corner of "the Market".

As years went by things changed - not the purchasing of material - but the way we went to "the Market". The vendors remained the same, purchases remained the same but instead of tagging along - we started lugging the bags.

Still more years went by and I started my own screen priniting business and where else could I get printing ink, screens, films and related material but at "the Market".

Now I have shifted to Bangalore. When ever I hear the word "Market", I do not think of KR Market in Bangalore, I still remember "Devaraja Market" - often being rediculed by my Bangalorean wife!!

The authorities have never heard of the idiom - "A stitch in time - saves nine". If only they had taken appropriate timely maintenance during the last 110 years (I don't remember any repairs ever being carried out in the last 35 years or so - other than when an unfortunate fire burnt out a portion of the area) we would not have had to voice such opposition.

This is no way to save our heritage. It looks more as a scheme wherein you let an object go bad due to neglect and then say it is too late to recover it. Then say as it has gone bad we need to replace it.

No way! I want to see my "Market" as I remember it. Nothing else will take the place of "Devaraja Market" in any other form.

Clean it up, build a different market place for the excess vendors, strengthen the building BUT DO NOT PUT IT DOWN!!!


__________________
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard